Search the Community

I'm glad there's a survey about one-star girls, but I feel it's incomplete and doesn't allow for very useful feedback to be given. Let me explain why and how it could be improved upon. 1/ Girls missing from the list Superstar-Boku-Mi-Maï Lily Bombshell-Arianne Curious-Claryssa Jasmyn Manuella Keira-At-Home Skimpy-Stephanie Sweet-Revenge Queen Leashed-Ria Night-Out-Judy Sassy-Bitch Anti-Bra-Deitra Punk-Astis Exotic-Zeina Ruthless-Maika Hospitable-Charlie Mistress-Ombresse Out of the current pool of 66 girls, 19 absent from the poll is a lot. And a fair number of these have the potential to have significantly below or above average scores. In my case, several favorites are on that list. 2/ No nuances allowed Having just a simple score from 1 to 5 for "the girl" as a whole makes little sense in general, but especially here. The goal of the survey is supposed to be finding out which 1-star girls a majority of players would have liked to see more of. You won't (correctly) identify that without differentiating at least between design/theme and execution/art quality. Many 1-star girls are obviously rushed jobs, very often based on shameless tracing of past girls' poses and affection scenes (including the same old drawing being recycled multiple times within the limited pool of 1-star girls themselves). A lot of them are also just poorly drawn, and/or drawn in a style that really doesn't suit HH's visual style (plenty of giant, dead eyes in there, among other issues). AND the number of undeniable mistakes (notably a left foot on a right leg) is through the roof compared to other girl types (another sign of how rushed it is). That deserves a low score in art quality. A low art quality doesn't mean we don't like the character, design and theme, let alone that we wouldn't like to see more (and better). The opposite is true. Some of them are well made but not particularly interesting or exciting in terms of design or theme. And everything in between of course. Which deserves a low score in inspiration. A low score in inspiration (design/theme) doesn't mean we dislike the art style and execution, though, let alone that we wouldn't like to see more (and more inspired) girls drawn in a similar way. As an experiment, I'll try to set up a complementary poll with the 19 missing girls listed above, for which I'll try to allow for two separate scores per girl (Art quality and Inspiration). Let's hope I can pull it off (I'm no Finder for polls ^^). Okay, actually that would be too many questions for the forum poll format. I'll try just the first 7 for now: Superstar-Boku-Mi-Maï Lily Bombshell-Arianne Curious-Claryssa Jasmyn Manuella Keira-At-Home

Well, you know the drill. I've been writing down my stats since the introduction of the controversial 1-star girl feature to the game. I'm sure many of you have been doing the same. On top of that, we have very little data yet, and the drop rate seems low. Let's share proper data and find out what's up. PROPER DATA: NOT "x shards in x fights" please, if you use x10 performances they can't count for the drop rate. We're looking to estimate the drop rate first and foremost, so we need to know "x shard drops in x fights". The drop range will figure itself out fast enough, just keep track of the smaller and larger amount of shards you obtained from a SINGLE FIGHT/SPIN. Thanks in advance. IMPORTANT: ONE POST PER PARTICIPANT (PLEASE EDIT IT TO UPDATE YOUR RESULTS, DON'T MAKE A NEW POST. THANKS. Edit: Clarified that it's not "if you use the x10 button you're out", but just "when you use the x10 button, those fights can't count for the drop rate data". Thanks @Slynia Edit: We have very little data yet, but so far the pessimistic hypothesis someone made on the feedback thread seems pretty likely (that they simply replaced the EPx1 orb with a range of shards as the reward, but kept the horrendous 1%-ish drop rate). =/ Thanks a lot to everyone contributing. We need as much (reliable) data as possible, especially since the drop rate seems very low, so it'll take a while to figure it out confidently. Edit: Simple template for easy copy-paste: Villains: X drops in X battles. Drop range: 0-0 GPx10: X drops in X GPx10 rolls. Drop range: 0-0 CONCLUSIONS: We know have pretty solid data on this (and by now most active players should have or be pretty close to have the 11 One-Grade Girls added so far). Here are the key info from our results: Drop rate from Villains is slightly above 1% (pre and post patch). Fixed amount per drop is 10 shards. Drop rate from GPx10 used to be around 10% (pre-patch) and is now around 20%. Fixed amount per drop: 5 shards. Full data compiled there: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1JojW0FOwg3ubF7_N-oD_7vVyuFteMnp_MlON8mRljZ8/edit?usp=sharing (thanks to @Tom208 for this table). Thanks again to everyone who contributed. I might revive this thread if there's a big change or they add a ton of these further down the line, otherwise, we got what we came for. Cheers. -------------- 2021/04/28: Big update. 35 new one-star girls added all at once. That's over thrice the total amount we had so far. I'm pinning this thread again and I'll start afresh for my stats just in case anything else has changed since we got the 11th one on April 1st. Anyone who'd like to participate again, thanks in advance for your help. 2021/05/19: New big patch change: all or nothing drops, and only on Dark Lord and Great Pachinko from now on. I'll update my previous count one last time and we can start sharing data for full drops with this new system. The patch is already live as of this writing. Thanks in advance to all participants for this new batch of data collection. Please make a fresh new post for this. Template updated: Dark Lord: X drops in X battles. (x100 drops only) GPx10: X drops in X GPx10 rolls. (x100 drops only)