EpicBacon

Brat Murane Get. Really good droprate. Since she was on Ninja Spy instead of Edwarda, the drops are different, xp books instead of cash/equipment orbs. I've broken down the different drops of Exp books in the second table. Brat Murane... err... Brats? her way into 5th out of 62/68 place. Edit: Had some leftover combativity, got the video after 67 fights.

with no claimable girls...

Sorry, been away for several days with no access to the game. I like to keep around 10 in stock just in case of emergencies, but I don't think I've bought too many this year, maybe 2-3? With the inclusion of Dp, one could argue that its a moot stat to include, then again some of the seasonal events sell cards that give combativity, and one could argue that that cost should be added to the girls, as you do get a lot of combativity from it. I don't really know, I guess it just made sense to add the sandalwood count when I started collecting the data, as buying them was usually the way to get hold of them, atleast in the quantity you needed at the time.

Cumkai Kelina get. She was not particularly interested in joining. I had several long stretches between drops, especially on the 4th sandalwood. I had charges left on sandalwood from previous event, so I only needed to use 4 this time. Cumkai Kelina cums in at 58th out of 61 mythic girls. Bad droprate, 5.27% vs the average 6.69%

Shinobi Karole Get: 673 fights/7.43% drop rate. Had really good droprate at the start, but some lackluster drops at the end even-ed it all out. Still, above average drops, so can't complain. Shinobi Karole infiltrates the leaderboard in 9th place.

Got another 3star love raid for kisses, Yana this time. But first I need to make a small correction, I listed Kaline as 132 kisses/18.18% droprate, this is slightly wrong. I made a mistake in my spreadsheet and forgot to add all battles to the total. This is the correct amount, with 156 kisses used, and a 15.38% droprate. Now for Yana Loveraid 191 kisses used, for a droprate of 13.61% This time around my most common sharddrop was 3x, with 6 instances, counting for 23.08% of all shards

Star Lover Salem get. (Summoner Salem skin) Decent luck on the first sandalwood, terrible drops on the second. Still comes in under average due to terrible luck on Red Pearl, dragging the average down.

I did have some losses too, but I did not count them as there was never a chance to roll for rewards.

Love Raid Kaline get. I used a total of 132 kisses, 18.18% shard droprate. My most common sharddrop was 6x, that counted for 25% of the shards. This seems to be correct, all my drops was in this range.

I've completed 1000 villain fights on both Edwarda and Nike while no events active, meaning no mythic orbs in the drop pool. 1000 fights shows Edwarda having a higher chance of dropping equipment orbs compared to Nike (+2.7%) Lets compare this to my previous snapshot at roughly 500 fights. Here we can see that Edwardas orb chance is the same at 18%, while Nike has dropped 1.43% (from 16.73% to 15.30%) We can also compare Edwardas villain fights against Edwardas mythic days drops. Equipment orb drops are down 2.82% from 20.82% to 18% Shard drops from mythic days Edwarda lines up against the increase in cash drops on villains (-6.63 shards against +6.37 cash) It should be noted that 1000 fights is a low sample size and while we can get some indicators from this, drop variance is contributing to these numbers.

Ah yes... of course, its another drop table from raid to villain girls, why didn't I think of that, that's so obvious... 🤔🤔

I think all 3 star girls can drop anything from 1-9 shards, so its going to be very luck dependent. I have Kaline Love Raid coming up in 16hours, I'll check how many kisses she takes me and report back here.

Pentra drill is the best feature they have added since laby. It has let me build up a stockpile of both books and affection items, however as you correctly state, gem supply is trending downwards.