Horsting

Definitely. When I heard about his first, since someone posted a link with session ID, so everyone on the forum was able to use his session and play his account, I thought it was some mistake/accident. Would have never expected this being by design by any serious website/game/whatever. It's like using user:password@host in the address bar, which modern browsers block, reasonably. _____________ Mission accomplished: Take care guys :).

I btw did not want to imply a blame by mentioning this, but to show that I tend to see the positive things and defend developer/design decisions. I know I am also a thick head, when I think I am right, and sometimes I see too late that I am wrong. And I am not always careful the way a write things, so it's easy to take my words more offensive than they were meant. With two or more similar characters like this, discussions can quickly heat up 😅. And yes, I certainly understand better where the negative expectations and frustration was and is coming from. Definitely. I mean, I was mentioning and criticising these things a lot within the last year, but bundling it once again was probably a needed part of finally drawing the line. Thanks, I am also very happy to finally did the choice. And indeed, being invested, also always seeing the next opportunity to catch a new girl around the corner, does not make it easier. I did just seriously finished 1st and 2nd CbC days as first, now have 5x 1st and 3x top 4 stashed for DP or LC 😄. No, I just saw DP and won't do something about it anymore. Will finish the league as 2nd (sadly switched too late to blue-eyes-blue-hair team, and one hard opponent), claim all those CbC rewards, invest them in my girls and that will be it :). I was also thinking and talking about quitting since months ago, said that I will most likely quite after watching the first weeks or the first Lust Race event, because it was a quite significant P2W feature added, compared to how the game was before. But I got over it, after all I was still able to get a fair amount of rewards from every LR without paying particularly for it. And to be true, HH is much less P2W than many other browser games I have seen in the meantime, and they listened to feedback (I guess) and relaxed LR, made it easier to get all girl. Actually one point where user feedback seems to have been taken into account. So on the P2W end, they actually did/do the balance act okay, IMO. But the time and attention consuming event repetition click work, paired with the quantity and quality of new and long standing bugs, was finally too much for me. One thing I took from it, is to always start playing any game as 100% F2P for one month. If I see no chance to reasonably progress at some point within this month, its too much P2W, and better to stop. Else, I should know until then whether the technical quality and efforts of the developers are worth to pay for, to get some speedup perks and such. ___________ Thanks for all your kind responses! Wishing you all the best, with or without HH (and/or clones) 👋.

Hey there, after 15 months I will stop playing Hentai Heroes, by the end of this league week. It has been an interesting time, a pleasure to chat and discuss with the community here (when I was still more active), and I also enjoyed parts of the game, especially the kinky and funny adventure story, which made me laugh loudly by times, the teasing art, and the challenge of beating even post level 600 veterans in the league, becoming a serious top 1 candidate with fixed top 4 position since, not sure, over 6 months at least. I crossed level 500 some weeks ago, did beat the hard labyrinth a few times without loosing a single girl (hard difficulty is unlocked once you reach level 500), and collected 32 mythic girls. However, I am posting here since I find it fair to give some feedback as serious power user, and also someone who did pay a fair amount of money for this game: I started with probably around 20 €/month, ended with almost strictly 15 €/month (season pass and gold card), which is also the maximum I see as actually fair for a game like this. I mean I was playing World of Warcraft in the past, when I was still in school, which did cost as well 15 €/month in average, which includes the fixed cost for buying it and extensions, when released. And does anyone seriously want to compare HH with the quality and efforts going into a game like World of Warcraft, with thousands of people involved in a complex full- and real-time 3D MMO 😉? But I know, inflation, and as F2P game, where most players (I guess) do not pay at all, there must be P2W elements for the others to compensate that, and whales to actually make profit. That is all fine, and a difficult balance act for sure. I am also software developer, have experience with web applications, maintaining a larger open source software project on my own, hosting a website, download server, software repository, blog, forum and all of this myself as well, so I can say that I know a bit what I am talking about, when it is about efforts, costs, end user support, maintenance/development/release cycles and all these things. I already mentioned some positive aspects above, art, story, generally the creative elements of the game, and at least the league as competitive element, which is for me the central game mode: Aside of trying to collect as many girls as possible, unlocking their art where I can, I do level, equip, skill, progress to be successful in league. Contests are also secondary for me: I do not want to win them for winning them, but for getting new girls and valuable resources, needed for becoming stronger in league. I was playing and paying for 15 months, so HH must have done something good enough. But I stop playing HH, because IMO there are some serious problems I want to outline. For me, it is not so much about how the game is right now, but about how I do not see it becoming better, but worse, by design, which I want to split into two main points: The Quality-, testing and bug fix management of Kinkoid is obviously horrible. I did not have much experience with browser games like this before, but I was shocked about the massive amounts of totally obvious/visible/major bugs that were introduced with (literally) every new feature, even with smaller updates, not being fixed for months or even years or ever until now. I can hardly imagine how the condition of the game developers/coders are so that such is even possible, where obviously no one is seriously testing or even carefully reviewing changes. There is a test server, which is sometimes used, sometimes not, but even when I am/we are testing new things there and report all the bugs, the changes/new features are just merged right away without any reported bug fixed. A prominent example is the league GUI rework, where sorting did not work, buttons were misplaced, the new booster indicators did not work (with several different bugs affecting this one feature for 9 months, IIRC), opponent stats (and own defensive stats) are often wrong until now, as well caused by a conglomerate of different entangled bugs, and much more. The introductions of girl skills just shortly after, when most of the league bugs were not fixed, introduced a bunch of new bugs, broke the x3 button (which is broken until now), and further broke opponent stats, since skills were not used at all after opponent boosters expired. Since the league is such a central element for me, I maintained a bug report thread about all of those, where you can see the history a bit, and all those things not fixed until today: Next prominent example was the Labyrinth. It was announced with the hint that it will be on test server for several weeks to assure we can test and give feedback, so I had the hope that this time it will be better than with the league and girl skills, while at the same time I was pissed that it was even worked on a new feature, while the long list of major league/skill bugs was still not yet addressed. I invested hours of my time to test it thoroughly on the test server and reported a long list of bugs and balance issues with much details, many of them trivial to fix. Well, IIRC, the Labyrinth was released not even a full week after I gave my feedback, without any change, full of major bugs and problems. IIRC the were some changes/balancing done a week later, which were again on the test server. However, the trivial, obvious and primary problems were not addressed, but balancing done on top a wrong base stats calculation (KH, CH and HC do not raise the girl stats as documented, which means that "tanks" are no good tanks and "mages" are no mages at all, but often better tanks), which is still wrong until now. I reported this over and over on Discord etc, and that every balancing done, while these basic stats mapping is still wrong, is complete nonsense. But I have been ignored 100% everywhere. Total frustration, and I never used the test server again for testing from that point on. What a waste of potential community efforts for raising the quality of the game. And damn, how is it possible that the club chat is started fully scrolled up to oldest messages since months, with only a tiny scroll button that is very hard to grab? Our club chatting has become significantly less since this, since people just do not see new messages, or are too lazy to always scroll down first to see whether something new has been posted. No one is perfect, and complex software always has bugs, so that is okay. What I am criticising is that I see zero efforts to make it better, after an obviously horrible feature introduction/update happened, even when announced. Yes, there were some weeks of bug fixes, with a bug fix survey, but it was a one time thing, fixing a few bugs (not all major ones), and afterwards many new were introduced, even some of those which were fixed before already. I have no idea how such is even possible. Like developers are working on an old branch/version of the code, and then force merge it, reverting bug fixes done on main branch in the meantime? Puhhh ... For me, on my software project, bug fixes have highest priority over everything else: If we find a bug, or users report it, all efforts are going into investigating and fixing it. There is no survey needed about which bug people want to have fixed first. It is mandatory standard for me that a known bug has at least tried to be fixed before working on any new feature. It is rare that a bug is outside of own abilities/responsibilities, like if it is in an external library, and especially when it is hardware-related, in kernel, firmware, drivers. But all HH bugs I reported and I am talking about here, are in the game code, or can be fixed/addressed in the game code. It just looks like KK has no real interest in doing this consequently, which I find unacceptable and incompatible with the natural ambition and honour I have as software developer to deliver a good quality product, which I do also expect from software I consume and pay for (fair or not). Related to this is the user feedback management. It is normal that one cannot make everyone happy. I talked about World of Warcraft, where also every update triggered a bunch of trolls in the forum to criticise every change, while I was almost always among the ones to defend the changes, try to explain the positive sides and that some criticism points are also factually wrong. I also defended the girl equipment here at first, which was much criticised by most of the community, and I was even blamed here for doing this, as a new player, in a probably too "aggressive" way. More than a year later, I am still confused that the (native game) GUI around managing girls gear is still extremely bad, very slow, zero overview over which girl currently wears what, has which bonuses etc. So yeah, if new features are dropped in like this, without caring about the GUI around, listening to user feedback and enhancing it accordingly, it is better to not introduce a new feature, IMO. Generally, I am confused that all those years where community scripts do heavy improvements (I would say mandatory improvements for any serious player) to the game GUI, absolutely none of those have been ever implemented into the game (ah, side of the "booster detector" script, however in a broken way for 9 months or so): several pages give very bad overview, require unnuecessary scrolling and navigation steps, where scripts provide a clean compacted version with no scrolling needed, better overview quicker navigation etc. In the game instead, some elements have become even larger requiring more scrolling and reducing the overview one has at a glace. Similarly the league's pre-battle page, which added the need to navigate back and forth whenever battling an opponent in league, while the main league page implies a lot of data load and processing, and is hence very slow. This was almost instantly reported as regression by many players, quickly addressed with a great/mandatory community script, but never been enhanced in the game itself. Instead, the x3 button, intended as time saver, is left broken until now. It is so easy to look through the features of the community scripts, which give free information about which aspects of the frontend need to be enhanced. But this potential has just been ignored. Another major point of criticism among the community is the constantly increasing time this game costs, which is also one major reason I do stop playing now. I am not generally about depth in games, like with girl equipment and skills, but the GUI around it has to allow dealing with this depth properly, which good overview and quick toggles/buttons/etc to manage things. If I have the impression that most of my time is pure click work, waiting for pages to load or skip buttons to pop up, then something is wrong, IMO, and I see my time wasted unnecessarily. This has never been addressed properly, so that e.g. the weekly adjustment of the league team(s) has become very time consuming, when aiming for top 4, at least (where fine tuning is needed), especially if not using community scripts. But more importantly than the GUI is the added new game modes, and increasing repetitions of existing game modes. Since I started, aside of girls' equipment and skills: - The number of monthly mythic events raised form 2 to 3. - The number of PoA events has been raised form 1 to 2. - The number of KC events has been raised from 1 to 2. - The number of seasonal (now "mega") events has been raised from 1 every 3 months to 1 every month. - A new contest with 6 days has been added (increasing the number of contest days and potential overlaps by 3). - The Labyrinth has been added as new game mode to be done every 2 days. - And as a negative synergy, many of these added events/modes give more energies rewards, which again cost time to deal with. Especially the large amount of added kisses take huge time to spend in season: similarly to x15 button in league, the x10 button in season cannot be used by any serious player, since the auto-choice is bad, breaking any ambition to compete with max PvP battles in e.g. LR and league top 1/4, of course. And those 10-20 minutes every day to click over and over battle, skip, ok, battle, skip, ok (at least I wrote a little own script to just hit RETURN for skip (and "ok", while it was broken in game code)), and often needed to wait 10 seconds before the new player draft appeared, because somehow the opponent choice timed out. This has been addressed now, but instead, I have almost always a 1-2 seconds delay, when the initial level/mojo limits are lifted to find opponents. No idea how such an operation, which should take milliseconds at the backend, can lead to any noticeable lag at the frontend. These 10-20 minutes every day, especially on those were I do the Labyrinth as well, are the most annoying minutes I face in this game. At the same time, there has been zero event/mode removal or speed up. This is easily doubled time invest for me since I started with the game, clicking through all these new GUI and game mode elements, increased season battles, and the same repeating event types over and over again. Instead, we got some statement from the boss that "playing 30 minutes is better/more interesting than playing 5 minutes" and we should not be so "nostalgic" or something like that, completely non-understanding or ignoring the point of our criticism. It makes sense to give new players the option to get older girls, but be a little creative about how to do that, instead of just adding repetitions of the same events. Shops are a good existing example, having also event girls stashed like PoP, CC and league girls are another one. There is zero reason to do any identical revival of any event, IMO. It is simple: Rosso and whoever is responsible, you have a full-time job, and you likely have a family and friends, which require a certain time daily. Now try to seriously play Hentai Heroes. With "seriously", I mean to participate in all events, finish the Labyrinth every 2 days, trying to compete in D3 league, min/max your PvP and PvE teams/girls etc, with the native game as it is, playing all its facets, using all resources. Do this for some months, then tell me that this is enjoyable and does not have a negative impact on your job and RL, and that the GUI around all those features is sane. Of course, you are not playing this game with such competitive/ambitious way, and this is okay. But then, listen and try to understand those who do, who constantly repeat over and over the same major points of criticism, while the game is constantly developing into the opposite direction, adding more and more repetitions, new buggy features around a too slow and non-fitting GUI to actually manage them properly. We started this game when it was more casual, and did consume less time, and we kept playing it because it was that casual and consumed that much time, at least most of us, which I read here on this forum. Of course you are free to develop this game for kids (who should not play it) with plenty of free time, but you will loose your veterans, like many who have gone already, and now me. I have no full insights into income/profit of this game, but the last time I saw derived user numbers from the LR event, it was decreasing. Similarly, most popular clubs seem to struggle keeping their number of users full. Two important forum moderators just vanished without leaving a note, at least three major community script developers stopped playing as well. So at last to me it looks like the direction of development and design does have a negative impact, and that it is not clever to ignore feedback that way, especially from the long playing veterans who make such an important base of this community, coding scripts, writing guides, doing testing, mechanics investigation etc. So TL; DR: I stop playing this game because it is not seriously taken care of delivering it with good quality and few bugs, and because it is not seriously listened to community feedback, especially about the increasing amount of time it costs to deal with the slow GUI any increasing event repetitions. Start to seriously review code, before merging it, seriously test it, with static code tests but also functional tests, and manual tests of new features. Let users test new features on the test server, and do listen to their feedback, addressing the bugs they find and report. Listen to your veterans which are so essential for the community, try to understand and take serious their feedback for game design directions. Much text, sorry for that, many here will know me in this regards 😄. Thanks to the community for all the nice conversation and interesting discussions, and I wish you all the best, with or without this game. After experiencing the past 15 months, I have no hope that this thread has any effect, or is even read by anyone responsible (it surely does not help that it is so long), but I did not want to let the opportunity go to drop off once again my thoughts 🙂. Take care, stay safe, assure to enjoy what you do and do what you enjoy.

Okay so it all works as expected, but some of you are in a level and mojo range, where simply no player is in range which gives more mojo and is beatable with high chance. What I would change is to make level and mojo upper and lower borders equal in all cases, so that one is always within the range of all players who are in one's range. Currently, it is possible that there are only 4 players within your range 16 - 25 levels below you are close to 1000 mojo below you (or ~87-75% level/mojo below you for low level/mojo values). In this case, both can be stuck: you get only 1 mojo for defeating them, and you are outside of their level range, hence they cannot get 40 mojo for defeating you. If their are not using #WeakInSeason teams, they may have also bad changes to beat each others, hence do only slowly catch up. This would certainly help with the problem, since whenever you see only 1 mojo opponents, you can be sure those see you as 40 mojo opponent, so that you can help them catch up with a #WeakInSeason team, to benefit from it later on.

Since I do get the expected mojo and also expected opponents offered at my level and mojo range, did you guys check whether the mojo you get is wrong (not 20 or up while you have some or less mojo), or whether you just get opponents with much less mojo than you? And if the latter, are there actually players in the leaderboard around you, within your level range, which could have been taken? Would be good to find out whether or what exactly is bugged. I mean there are always circumstances where you are just alone in your mojo and level range for a while, so just seeing low points for 1-2 days is not a prove of a bug.

Thanks, sadly adding the filters key as empty list did not help either. On the phone it works, so it has to do something with this browser. Again, I cleared all cookies and browser data, and it is still broken. I'll open a ticket.

There was this bug in the past where leading the season was hanging for 10 or 20 seconds, because the system could not find 3 opponents (excluding the ones from last draft) within the level and mojo range. And then often one had a doubled entry (same opponent two times), or one completely outside of the expected range. However, since a longer time I did not face this anymore, so I thought it was fixed already. Now the patch notes contain exactly the suggestion I made that time: to raise the level and mojo ranges for valid opponents, if no 3 could be found, instead of letting the system running into some timeout. No idea why this was even still required, and obviously, while it on its own is a reasonable change, it broke things elsewhere.

Since the menu does not expand, there is no "reset filters" button visible. I tried to remove the related keys form local storage, but that did not help either. Could you show your local storage keys? Probably the filter key requires a valid entry. In my case it is not defined now, and only the sorting and grid keys are generated automatically so far.

Am I the only one affected by non-expanding (classic) harem filters? Simply nothing happens, when I click the filter button, only the selected girl's class icon disappears, likely to make more space for the filters. This happens independent of any scripts 🤔. No error in browser console, not any other hint I could find. Clearing cache etc does not help.

Ah thanks for the info. I just wanted to try it, but today's update seems to have broken the harem filter, which does not slide in anymore (with and without scripts) 😑. Nice idea to fetch girl data from opponents 👍. @renalove since the Harem++ collector seems to not work anymore at all, what do you think about the idea to use the HH++ harem data, if available? The HHPlusPlusGirlDictionary value needs to be base64-decoded and then gzip-decompressed to get the JSON, or just import and use the HH++ Helpers. Seems to make more sense to me than fixing/developing an own collector, doubling processing and storage, for those which use both apps. Best would be probably a JavaScript library for the collector, which can be used by all apps, and loaded only once by whichever app does so first 😄. I could try to come up with a PR or patch which implements this, if wanted, but your time rare.

@zoopokemon @renalove Is there any idea how to collect data about girls one does not have all shards yet? Some weeks ago, while debugging something, I accidentally purged the local store. Since then, the shards batch for all those cases are unknown to HH++, at least until I collect another shard: Browsing through all those girls in the classic harem does not help. Not sure if there is a good way to collect data when new girls are loaded while scrollen the harem? Better than nothing, at least. In case of Harem++, I was surprised that its old snapshot of girl data and shards survived, and realised that it uses the "cache storage" instead, which I didn't know about: Seems to be a good idea for larger amounts of data, which could hit the local storage limit. However, the problem is the same, the shards counts are outdated (stuck at 26th January, the games harem performance update) and new girls added to the game do not appear in the traits filter, until one has 100 shards of them. Not sure which info is available from girls below 100 shards, and where, but probably both apps can contribute to and share the same harem cache with a new collector. I'll have a look into it the next days.

I was a little lucky this time: one Pachinko-only girl from EPx1 during DD and the other one from 1/1 EvP. Only 40 girls left in EP pool, so 2 more DDs and I'm finally able to assure the CE chest and farm OD girls more effectively.

There are already two reports where logout and login helped. Worth an attempt 🙂.

I needed only 25 CP to get the video, which I had left from past ME cards. I would have never bought or claimed extra CP for this, so guess I was lucky. I got it while there were shards. There is no one who confirmed a video drop while there were no shards, right?

In my club someone with the same issue says that logout and login helped. Better than sacrificing the remaining team, so worth an attempt until KK fixed it.